I've been waiting for WSGF to review this thing for a long time. I own a TH2Go analog, and I'm pretty dissatisfied with it because of image problems at 75 or 85 Hz. I run 3 22" CRTs, so thats important to me.
You touched on a lot of good points... but I cant help but feel the review is lacking. Please don't feel that I'm bashing your review (its well done!) but I'd like to provide some constructive criticism. For example:
I'm not sure if either of these resolutions exceeds the bandwidth in Dual-Link DVI. If not, maybe a firmware update might come our way one day, even for 3x1440x900.
It sounds like you didn't think it was worth the effort to research those things in order to provide an informed review for your audience. Further, you go into pure speculation. That sounds more like forum post material than something that belongs in a review. Perhaps it would be more appropriate to do a kind of 'open request to Matrox' by saying "We know DX10 is capable of higher resolutions, so why are you still limiting us to 3840x1024 Matrox?" Better than that would be to contact Matrox with these concerns and include their answer (or lack thereof) in the review.
Some other things I'd like to see answered:
- Monitor setups. A common question on the forums is 'Can I run my widescreen LCD with two 4:3 LCDs on the sides? It needs to be clearly spelled out that the monitors must be the same, and they must be able to display these resulotions. I'm thinking specific examples of common setups that will and will not work.
- Analag display? Not everyone has digital monitors, and not everyone runs LCDs at all. Hows the analog capabilities, is the image quality noticably different than digital? Does it work ok on CRTs at 75/85Hz?
- Usage in windows? The review touches on this briefly, but not much.
- What types of games work best? Other reviews out there have commented that triple head is not so great in RTS games, alright in RPGs and FPS games, and absolutely fantastic with flight sim and racing games. Matrox's new Surround Gaming Zone has specific sections for Flight Sim and Racing games... but your review doesnt even mention these categories.
- SGU support - A definate negative to the TH2Go that isn't really mentioned. I'm thinking of things like the common Id engine games that require a special hack to work right and dont have SGU support.
Maybe my expectations are too high, but its only because I think of this place as the best resource (heck, pretty much the ONLY resource) for triplehead goodness. :)